Global Edition

Máximo Kirchner put down the GTA VI controller to threaten investments

By Comunicaciones Mineras
Máximo Kirchner put down the GTA VI controller to threaten investments
Kirchner cuestionó beneficios del RIGI y prometió «armar quilombo» alrededor de las reglas de inversión.

Máximo Kirchner set aside his PlayStation for a moment to discuss investments. During the presentation of Porvenir, he called for an audit of benefits granted under the Large Investment Incentive Regime (RIGI). When addressing criticism of his proposal, he chose to close with a warning: "We're going to stir up all the chaos that needs stirring up."

The problem isn't requesting audits. A company receiving benefits must comply with conditions established by law and submit to oversight. The problem is the casualness with which Kirchner turns a discussion about rules for large-scale investments into a display of political force. As if the country were a game of GTA VI: you try a decision, create a mess and, if it goes wrong, you reload the last saved point.

Argentina doesn't have that button. For years, anyone wanting to invest had to calculate more than their project costs: restrictions on importing equipment, obstacles to accessing foreign currency, foreign exchange controls and the gap between the official dollar and parallel exchange rates. Add to that a persistent question: whether the rules agreed upon when beginning an investment would still be in effect when production time arrived.

The RIGI attempts to address that mistrust. It offers incentives and regulatory stability for thirty years to large-scale projects in sectors such as energy, oil and gas, mining, infrastructure, technology and industry. It doesn't guarantee by itself that each investment will be worthwhile nor does it exempt any company from complying with the law. But it acknowledges a problem that Kirchner seems to overlook: securing capital for projects that take years to develop requires some certainty about future conditions.

An energy project isn't built on a slogan. An industrial plant isn't financed by a speech. And a mining investment doesn't move forward because a politician declares he wants more employment. Capital is needed, permits, infrastructure, suppliers, workers and time. Before putting all that in motion, investors assess whether the country will keep its word. When a congressman with political ambitions promises "chaos" around those rules, he adds an uncertainty that he won't have to pay for.

Kirchner argued that the Government cares more about electoral debate than about jobs and wages. He also questioned why universities and pension beneficiaries are audited while, according to his reasoning, oil and mining companies aren't. These are matters that can and should be discussed. What's missing from his discourse is a precise explanation: what breaches he detected, what benefits he would reconsider and how he would guarantee that projects that acted in accordance with the law retain their rights. Without those answers, his proposal looks more like a threat than a control policy.

Argentina already knows the cost of changing conditions halfway through. It also knows the result of requesting investments while its leaders compete to see who makes the most noise. After so many failures, whoever wants to lead the country should speak seriously about oversight, development and stability. If Máximo Kirchner prefers to overturn the table every time a rule doesn't suit him, he'd better stick to playing PlayStation.