Conditional Social License: Mining Has Support, But Now Governments Must Sustain It

Analyst Sergio Berensztein closed this Friday's Sustainable Mining Summit in Mendoza with an assessment of mining's representation in the country, the degree of acceptance, and the challenges to sustaining the social agreement it has. One of the most relevant findings is that 75% support foreign investment for the industry.
The prejudice that middle-class urban sectors held fifteen or seventeen years ago has gradually eroded. Today, he said, "it has been reduced to a very limited segment of the population." And another figure reinforces this: 97% would approve a project that meets environmental criteria, transparency standards, and respect for communities. "We practically see an almost ideal environment," he summarized, especially when compared with other countries with significant mining presence.
Support is broad, but it also comes with demands
The key to the study lies in the conditional nature of that 97%: if it complies. Support is not a blank check, and the sector's challenges begin where the survey ends.
The first is water. 54% demand its protection as a primary condition. "There is enormous concern about water. It's not a restriction, it's simply a yellow light," Berensztein stated, a yellow light that demands clear information and technology. In a country where many projects develop in arid regions, the issue is almost an "obsession," he admitted, and it is "understandable why." Mendoza is, for him, the best example: "If anyone knows about this, it's the people of Mendoza."

Sergio Berensztein presented a study on the social agreement around mining nationwide and left homework for governments.
The Trust Challenge
The second is trust, and here the diagnosis is tough. "People distrust the actors most involved in the industry, they distrust the public sector, they distrust the media, but they trust the university system," he stated. 54% believe primarily in reports from scientists and technicians, particularly from CONICET and public and private universities.
Hence his proposal: "Universities and the epistemic community must be incorporated into a cooperative framework." That community, he said, can be "a beacon that illuminates society" about what the industry does and doesn't do.
Trust, he added, is built with transparency. Controls must be independent, results public, and language accessible, because technical jargon "creates barriers to entry for people to understand." He even urged to "overstate transparency policies" and quoted his grandmother: "Being and appearing."

Sergio Berensztein warned about the challenges for mining that includes all sectors and delivers benefits on a daily basis.
The study's direct quotes show what doubt persists: "Who controls and by what rules?", "Knowing whether the State has the capacity to control."
The Knowledge and Expectations Challenge
Only a third of society says it knows much or enough about the industry, even in mining provinces. It's a new activity, and that vacuum fills with anxiety. Investment announcements are impressive, but "implementing these projects takes time," and the idea of immediate benefits is something "we all know is impossible." Managing those expectations, he affirmed, "is one of the vital elements moving forward."
The Employment and Value Chain Challenge
Mining, he recalled, doesn't demand only extraction and processing workers: it needs truckers, metalworking companies, technology suppliers, engineering services, shops, and restaurants. That dimension, according to the study, still isn't visible, and it's a communication opportunity. The same applies to benefits people don't associate with the industry, such as internet, transportation, health, and education.
But Berensztein warned against the legislative shortcut. Many provinces mandate hiring local personnel, and his assessment is blunt: "If we force regulations without first training people, everyone loses. We must coordinate with technical schools and universities to prepare local talent in time and avoid chasing problems." His underlying position: "I don't believe in regulatory measures by imposition." He prefers to generate supply and demand conditions.
The Planning Challenge
The case to avoid is Vaca Muerta, with its infrastructure and service bottlenecks. "That can be prevented with planning. It's not something Argentina does well, let's remember," he said, and pointed to discontinuity between governments as a cause. His recipe is an early public-private effort, because "when you're chasing problems, it's harder and more costly."
Provinces as Protagonists, With Greater Responsibility
Since the 1994 reform, provinces own natural resources, something Berensztein considers "a fundamental institutional transformation." For Catamarca or Jujuy, mining is the "first development vector" that puts them on the world map. He anticipates "small Neuquenes" throughout the mining basin and a shift in "the country's political geography" within two or three decades.
That protagonism demands capacity. Many provinces lack the human capital or accumulated experience to negotiate as equals, so the initiative, he argues, must come from industry, with its international knowledge and "a menu of alternative solutions."
In Favor of Foreign Investment
Despite a "fairly clear" future for flagship projects, there persists "a residual undercurrent of nationalism" and prejudice against foreign capital. Unlike Vaca Muerta, most mining projects have external participation, partial or total. There, he argued, each project must be explained more precisely: benefits, requirements, and control mechanisms.
The underlying message is simple. Society has already given its permission, nationwide. Keeping it will depend on whether industry and governments live up to what is demanded of them.
